Techno-economic analysis
Does the physics pay for itself?
A transparent, literature-anchored model comparing a continuous sonochemical (acoustic + microwave) beneficiation stage bolted onto an existing flowsheet against a conventional acid-digestion / solvent-extraction baseline. Every figure is an illustrative, literature-derived placeholder, a framework to reason with, not a commercial quote.
How to read this model
This is a micro-level, marginal analysis. It estimates the economics of adding one continuous sonochemical beneficiation stage to an existing conventional flowsheet at a single illustrative plant: 100 t/day throughput, 0.5% REE grade, $90/kg NdPr. Every figure is a literature-derived placeholder — a framework to reason with, not a commercial quote.
To claim these numbers apply to every mine, grade, or price environment would obviously be false. Deposit chemistry, scale, energy cost, labour regimes, and existing infrastructure all shift the economics. What this model is useful for is showing the directional leverage of recovery uplift in a continuous intensification stage, and how sensitive that leverage is to price and recovery assumptions.
At a macro scale, the picture is different — and much larger. The global rare-earth industry loses a significant share of in-situ REE value to recovery shortfalls and reagent intensity across thousands of tonnes per day. If continuous intensification can recover even a few additional percentage points across a meaningful share of that throughput, the aggregate annual value creation runs into the billions. This model is one small, rigorously bounded step toward understanding that larger opportunity.
Net annual benefit
$1.66M
Revenue uplift + environmental proxy − incremental cost.
Simple payback
~0.45 yr
Equipment capex / net annual benefit.
Benefit–cost ratio
5.2×
Gross benefit / incremental annual cost.
Incremental cost
$0.39M/yr
Amortisation + labour + electricity only.
The incremental cost covers only the new acoustic / microwave equipment (amortisation, labour, electricity) added to an existing process. Revenue uplift comes from a conservative +12 pp recovery gain. This is a marginal add-on case, not a full greenfield plant TEA.
Baseline vs. proposed stage
| Metric | Conventional | Proposed | Delta |
|---|---|---|---|
| REE recovery rate | 60% | 72% | +12 pp |
| REE recovered | 99,000 kg/yr | 118,800 kg/yr | +19,800 kg/yr |
| Revenue | $8.91M/yr | $10.69M/yr | +$1.78M/yr |
Sensitivity
Net annual benefit ($/yr) across recovery uplift (rows) and REE price (columns). The base case, +12 pp uplift at $90/kg, is highlighted. Below zero, the added stage does not pay for its own electricity, labour and amortisation.
| Uplift \ Price | $53/kg | $90/kg | $110/kg | $140/kg |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| 0 pp | -$393k | -$393k | -$393k | -$393k |
| +6 pp | $267k | $633k | $831k | $1.13M |
| +12 pp | $926k | $1.66M | $2.05M | $2.65M |
| +18 pp | $1.59M | $2.68M | $3.28M | $4.17M |
| +24 pp | $2.24M | $3.71M | $4.50M | $5.69M |
Key assumptions
Ore throughput
100 t/day
Illustrative mid-scale staged line, adjustable.
Operating days / year
330
Typical industrial uptime.
REE grade in feed
0.5%
Illustrative secondary / tailings-grade feedstock (ion-adsorption clay / mine-waste range).
REE price (NdPr basis)
$90 / kg
SMM benchmark, 1 Jun 2026. 2026 range $53–$140/kg; DoD-backed floor $110/kg.
Conventional recovery
60%
Illustrative acid-digestion / SX recovery benchmark.
Recovery uplift
+12 pp
Conservative extrapolation from leach-rate / yield gains in the literature.
Proposed recovery
72%
Conventional recovery + uplift.
Conventional cash OPEX
$30 / kg
Midpoint of $20–50/kg reported for advanced-stage REE projects.
Added acoustic + microwave capacity
50 kW
Illustrative for a 100 t/day staged line.
Equipment capex (one-time)
$750,000
From public ultrasonic / inline-homogeniser pricing.
Sources
Process / cost data
Brown et al., Sustainable Chemistry, 2025, 6(4):33, doi.org/10.3390/suschem6040033
REE price ($90.32/kg NdPr, 1 Jun 2026)
Shanghai Metals Market (SMM) benchmark; metal.com
DoD-backed price floor ($110/kg)
MP Materials / US DoD contract reporting, 2026
Industrial electricity ($0.085/kWh)
US EIA, 2026 industrial-sector price projection
Conventional REE OPEX ($20–50/kg)
Techno-economic analyses of advanced-stage REE projects, 2024–2026
Ultrasonic equipment capex ($10k–60k/kW)
Hielscher UIP2000hdT; GEA DiSonic inline homogeniser, public pricing, 2026
Tailings / NORM remediation ($0.12–$68/t)
Uranium mill tailings remediation programs incl. US UMTRA Title I